
…it exists not by nature but by law, and it is in our power to change it and make it useless.Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics
By law, not by nature
The story
The coin on the poster is an Athenian tetradrachm, four drachmas in silver, struck with Athena's owl on one side and the goddess's face on the other. It was simply called the owl. For a few hundred years it was the most widely used coin in the Mediterranean, accepted from Sicily to Egypt, not because anyone ordered it but because the silver always weighed what it should.
Aristotle lived in the middle of that world. In the fifth book of the Nicomachean Ethics, written in the fourth century BC, he tries to explain what happens when a shoemaker and a builder want to trade with each other. A house and a pair of shoes cannot be compared. So a third thing is needed to make them comparable, a common measure. That measure is money.
Then he makes an observation about language. The Greek word for coin, nomisma, comes from nomos, which means law or custom. Money is called what it is called because it is an agreement. It exists not by nature, he writes, but by law. And what exists by law can be changed by law. It is in our power to make money worthless.
That was not a warning. It was a description. Aristotle saw that even a silver coin of the right weight only works as money as long as people agree to accept it. The metal is metal. The money is the agreement.
History proved him right in the most literal way. Roman emperors diluted the silver in the denarius until it contained almost nothing but copper. Kings clipped the edges of coins and struck new ones from the shavings. Every time it was the same mechanism: whoever has power over the law has power over what money is worth.
Today there is no silver left to dilute. Kronor, dollars and euros are agreements through and through, numbers on accounts that rest on states, banks and ordinary people continuing to trust them. That is exactly what Aristotle described, only without the metal. And that is why the question on the poster cannot be answered once and for all. What money is depends on what we have agreed, and that can change.
Download
Free for personal use. Not for resale.
Be there from the start
The service has not launched yet. Join the waitlist and we will be in touch when we open.
Investing involves risk. Your savings can go both up and down in value.